Without a doubt, it is safe to say that the assigned articles revolve around ethics in contemporary design. Whether it was “ Critique of the American Apparel’, ‘ First Things First 64 and 2000 Manifestos’, or ‘ The Responsibilities of the Design Profession’, they all played off of one another as a group to create a view with various angles on today’s design. That is why it’s important to speak of these articles as a group rather than try to deconstruct them piece by piece.
Even before reading it, the most appealing article of them all was the ‘Critique of the American Apparel’. One reason being advertisement. Its provoking designs have met the media plenty of times, which immediately cast a lasting impression of the company in my mind. The article speaks about the ways that are used to bring consumers in. However, the images of young looking girls in a submissive state show the viewer much more than the style of a shirt or the pants the model is wearing. This can particularly clash with the thoughts of the 60’s where designers tried to gear design toward more conservative causes, such as designing book, signs, industrial photography etc… They were trying to establish more useful ways of communication through the skills of design, as seen in the Manifesto 64’ article.
Furthermore, the Manifesto of 2000 shows that design has now merged same paths with advertising and now are both predominately one of the same. Viewers are now even lured into the image and persuaded by the particular design to go after the product or idea being advertised. It shows that contemporary design is more about the designed product manipulating the way a viewer feels. Poyner however, sill believes as in the 60’ that design should be useful and lasting, but unfortunately it is a factor today’s design still lacks. This is mainly because according to Poyner, today’s designers’ creations are mostly based on the ‘political choice’, meaning rather than having the design used for a lasting purpose, it is used for corporate/commercial purposes.
The article which personally seems the base for the other readings is that of Herbert Spencer and ‘ The Responsibilities of Design Profession.’ Because it was still written in the 60’s, it remains vital for the minds of contemporary designers. The addressed issues in the article are the products of entering a new era in design. Designers being motivated to out do the other, losing of the printing tradition, and overall design becoming more advanced or complex created the system designers live in today. Whether it’s American Apparel or any other company which tends to exploit and use design in a seemingly unethical way according to the original manifesto, they give design this new/ contemporary feel which was never felt before the 60’s. It is important, however, to move forward and develop design and its characteristics because design is essential to the way one views the world and its assets through it.